Request to view video refused

District can’t disclose information that could invade ‘personal privacy’

A freedom of information request to view the video of the entire Maple Ridge committee of the whole meeting on June 17 has been rejected by the district’s freedom of information officer, Ceri Marlo.

The request was made by The News after the video was removed from the district website, then reposted with some parts of the video excised.

According to Mayor Ernie Daykin, the video was removed because some comments by Coun. Corisa Bell could be considered defamatory, according to the district’s lawyer.

“Legal counsel has offered an opinion that the possibility exists that your remarks could give rise to an action in defamation,” Daykin told Bell in a June 25 letter.

The legal action could come from the staff member involved.

The district could be liable if it republished those comments by posting the video on its website, the mayor said in a letter to Bell.

But in the letter from Marlo, the Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Act is cited as justification for not releasing the video.

Under the act, the district can’t disclose information that would “unreasonably invade the personal privacy” of a third party.

“The act gives the district no discretion in such cases – we are legally obligated to refuse access.”

She writes in her explanation that the comments can be described in general terms as a “negative, critical assessment” of the performance of an identifiable employee.

Marlo adds that “public exposure of untested allegations by a council member about an employee’s performance may unfairly damage the employee’s reputation …” – something which must be considered under the FOI act.

That’s why such matters are usually dealt with in closed meetings.

The comments also were ruled out of order by the chair, which is a critical factor because it shows that the chair considered that the matter wasn’t fully discussed.

However, media lawyer David F. Sutherland said earlier that comments in a public meeting are unlikely to lead to a lawsuit.

“There’s a very wide protection for a fair and accurate report, which a videotape would be, of a council meeting,” under Sec. 4 of the Libel and Slander Act.

Sutherland said if publishing what happens at a council meeting has an ulterior motive, there is a limit to the privilege, but it’s not exceeded by a councillor’s questioning of budgets at a council meeting.

“That is really highly unlikely,” he said. “There are so many other checks and balances.”

Councillors are in the business of public service, he added.

“The idea that somebody’s private reputation should interfere in the dissemination of information about what goes on in the public sphere is really troublesome to me.”

Bell has seen the video and her lawyer can view the video at municipal hall. Her lawyer also can get his or her own copy.

Bell maintains the video should be public.

Just Posted

Class sizes dropped from among the worst in B.C.

Maple Ridge trustees review statistics

Heavy downpours expected in parts of Metro Vancouver

Heavy rain will begin to ease off Sunday evening as the frontal system moves south out of the area

Another Friday night fire in Maple Ridge

Abandoned house in Silver Valley area burns

Police investigate string of overnight fires in North Delta

Suspected arson caused damage to vehicles, signage in the area, Delta Police say

MacDuff: Memories at the kitchen table

It was tradition to attend the Remembrance Day service with my mom,… Continue reading

Maple Ridge remembers

Remembrance Day ceremony and parade in downtown Maple Ridge.

Crash shuts down Highway 91 in Richmond for hours

The stretch of highway was closed for more than 6 hours due to a multi-vehicle accident

VIDEO: Rare comic showing Superman’s 1st appearance to be auctioned

The 1938 comic features Superman hoisting a car over his head

Pine beetles from Jasper National Park moving into commercial forest

In 2014, beetle activity went from a few spots around Jasper’s townsite to rampant

VIDEO: Tragically Hip members, Alex Trebek receive Order of Canada

Newest recipients join 6,897 Canadians such as Christine Sinclair, Graham Greene and Mark Messier

AC/DC’s Malcolm Young dies at 64

‘Malcolm was a songwriter, guitarist, performer, producer and visionary who inspired many.’

‘I will now live in consistent fear’: Allan Schoenborn granted escorted leaves

The Merritt man was deemed not criminally responsible in the killing of his three children in 2008

Hammy the deer dodges conservation officers in Prince Rupert

The famous Prince Rupert hammock deer maintains his purple threads

‘No shirt, no service, no Canada’

Shirtless Tacoma man arrested after Canadian border officials say they found meth in rental vehicle

Most Read