District of Maple Ridge has the right to clean up video, says SFU professor

Maple Ridge resident claims Local Government Act does not give the mayor or council the authority to “retroactively close a meeting.”

As much as Maple Ridge councillors want it to go away, the issue of the edited video awaits their return from summer break.

Council watcher Grover Telford will challenge the district’s authority to “censor” a video of a public meeting.

The issue arose when the municipality’s lawyer advised council that comments by Coun. Corisa Bell at a June 17 committee of the whole may be libelous toward a member of district staff. She was commenting about the budget process.

The video of the meeting was taken off the website, edited, and then returned with the controversial comments taken out. Bell has been allowed to view the video in its entirety.

Council has been publicly challenged for the move, with critics saying they are stifling dissent from Bell.

Telford said he has investigated the matter, and the Local Government Act does not give the mayor or council the authority to “retroactively close a meeting.”

He cites a section of the act which says municipal records must be available for public inspection, and that if a meeting is to be closed, then council must state that before the meeting, and by resolution.

At council’s last meeting on July 23, councillors were united in saying they are open, do not try to discourage “tough questions,” and want to put the matter of the video behind them.

But Telford, a failed council candidate who says he will run on a slate of candidates in the next municipal election, plans to be at the Aug. 27 meeting to raise his questions.

He said the action council has taken “flies in the face of democracy.”

“In the court of public opinion, it is obviously censorship.”

Political scientist Gordon Price, who was on Vancouver city council for 15 years, and is now the director of the district program at Simon Fraser University, believes the municipality is on solid footing.

Acknowledging he does not know the contents of the video, and is not a lawyer, Price said Maple Ridge could be exposing itself to a libel lawsuit if it ignored legal advice.

“If you didn’t take the advice, you’ve got a double problem,” he said.

“The city is covering its ass.”

Price said council videos are not regarded in law as formal Hansard, and do not constitute the legal record of the meeting.

He also noted that even the Hansard from the House of Commons in Ottawa is edited for clarity. “My guess is yes, they’re probably okay on that,” said Price.

“If the city didn’t take action, and were sued for slander, their only defence would be that they were not allowed to change it (the video) – and I’m not aware of that.”

The municipality does not have any legal obligation to post its videos online.

Telford is not the only person who wants answers about the video. Community activist Nicole Read made a freedom of information request asking for a copy of the video.


Just Posted

Sea bus service proposed along Fraser River

Maple Ridge councillor just wants to start discussion

Pitt Meadows gets some help for flood plan

$412,000, but not for dike upgrades

Maple Ridge, Pitt Meadows folks take in rides at PNE

Fall exhibition heralds end of summer

Pantracia Chronicles paves path for Pitt Meadows author

First trilogy in epic fantasy series released this year

Homes found for abandoned hedgehogs in Maple Ridge

Lucky new owners picked up their pets on Aug. 20

Pickle me this: All the outrageous foods at this year’s PNE

Pickled cotton candy, deep-fried chicken skins, and ramen corndogs are just a start

New study suggests autism overdiagnosed: Canadian expert

Laurent Mottron: ‘Autistic people we test now are less and less different than typical people’

B.C. father tells judge he did not kill his young daughters

Andrew Berry pleaded not guilty to the December 2017 deaths

Trans Mountain gives contractors 30 days to get workers, supplies ready for pipeline

Crown corporation believes the expansion project could be in service by mid-2022

Mammoth sturgeon catch was ‘a fish of a lifetime’ for Chilliwack guide

Sturgeon was so enormous it tied for largest specimen every tagged and released in the Fraser

Rosemount cooked diced chicken linked to listeria case in B.C.

The symptoms of listeria include vomiting, nausea, fever, muscle aches

Body found believed to be missing Chilliwack senior with dementia

Police say case is now in the hands of the coroner

B.C. seniors allowed more choice to stay in assisted living

Province doesn’t need to wait for a complaint to investigate care, Adrian Dix says

Most Read